Thursday, December 26, 2013

A Christmas Carol - 7th Grade

I'm a little late with this post, but I need some help. We recently read this classic novel as a part of our seventh grade curriculum. As a building we are looking at reviewing and revising our book list for grades 6, 7 and 8. I am stuck. I like this novel, but I'm not sure if we should keep it. It seems that I have as many questions as answers for this task. I have some pros and cons for reading the book as a class at the 7th grade level.

Pros:

  • The book is full of figurative language that can be dissected and analyzed
  • There are many play and movie versions that offer many opportunities to compare and contrast different writing styles and viewpoints
  • There are many themes, but they really don't dwell on one singular theme of Christmas
Cons:
  • The 1800's. The language is so different and is really tough for the students to get through at times
  • The chapter length makes it hard to divide it into equal parts
  • Dickens. I love the guy, but students, not so much. The lexile is about right for middle school, but it seems like it is challenging at times for students.
  • Timing. Do we have enough time between Thanksgiving and Christmas to read it all and teach it effectively?
So that is where I am with this novel. I can't decide what to do here. So, I'm crowd sourcing this thing. Let me know what you think. I you read it or have read it at the middle school level let me know. Thanks.